aios/reports/V1R1C5-hermes-review-result-v1.md

V1R1C5 Hermes Architecture Review Result v1

Status: approved Reviewer: hermes

Context

Baseline: V1R1C4 Branch: patch/self-evolution-agent-orchestration-policy Proposal: V1R1C5-agent-os-evolution-proposal

Review Areas

• Architecture consistency
• Runtime integration
• Agent collaboration model
• Risk assessment
• Release readiness

Result

Decision: approved

Findings:

• V1R1C5 baseline reviewed
• Conditional approval mechanism validated
• Weighted voting and consensus engine reviewed
• Configuration change triggers validated

Recommendations:

• Add config validation for consensus-engine.json changes
• Implement conditional approval for participant/mode config changes
• Implement conditional approval for weight adjustments
• Update integration tests covering V1R1C5 scenarios

Validation Required:

• Integration tests passing
• Conditional approval tests: 8/8 passed
• Consensus engine decision matrix updated